Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

The Village Pump menu

18 dishes across 5 sections American restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu The Village Pump photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

The Village Pump photo menu 1 The Village Pump photo menu 2 The Village Pump photo menu 3 The Village Pump photo menu 4 The Village Pump photo menu 5 The Village Pump photo menu 6 The Village Pump photo menu 7 The Village Pump photo menu 8 The Village Pump photo menu 9 The Village Pump photo menu 10

FOOD - SOUPS & SALADS 10 dishes

  • Chicken Noodle Soup US$8.95

    Homemade!

  • Chili US$9.95

    Add Cheese Or Onions For 50¢ Each

  • Large Mixed Green Salad US$9.95

    w/ Cheese, Egg, Tomato, Onions

  • Side Salad US$7.95

    Mixed Greens, Shredded Cheese, Diced Tomatoes, & Diced Red Onions

  • Spinach Salad US$12.95

    Fresh Spinach, Egg, Bacon, Onion, Mushrooms, Tomato,& Mozzarella Cheese, Served w/ Balsamic

  • Small Spinach Salad US$8.95

    Spinach, Tomatoes, Onion, Mozzarella Cheese, and Bacon. Served with Balsamic Vinaigrette

  • Cole Slaw US$4.95

    Served w/ Garlic Bread

  • Cup Of Slaw US$2.50

  • Richie’s Famous Lobster Chowder US$15.00

  • Power Salad Bowl US$12.95

FOOD - STARTERS 16 dishes

  • Bag Of Chips US$1.00

  • Cheese Curds US$8.95

    Garlic Cheese Curds From Wisconsin

  • French Fries US$7.95

    Basket Of French Fries To Share

  • Fried Green Beans US$8.95

    Served With Horsey Sauce

  • Nachos US$15.95

    Piled High w/ Cheese, Tomatoes & Onions. Served w/ Sour Cream & Salsa

  • Onion Rings US$9.95

    Served w/ Bistro Sauce

  • Pretzel US$9.95

    Served w/ Beer Cheese Dip

  • Small Fries US$3.95

  • Steak Bites US$17.95

    Sirloin Steak Grilled w/ Mushrooms & Onions & Served Over Garlic Bread

  • Tenders US$11.95

    4 Tenders Served w/ BBQ Sauce

  • Walleye Bites US$16.95

    Lightly Breaded Lake Erie Walleye Bites. Hand Cut.

  • Wings US$19.95

    Plain Buffalo BBQ Garlic Parmesan

  • Cheeseburger Sliders US$12.95

  • Ahi Tuna US$19.95

  • Chicken Sliders US$12.95

    Three Fried Chicken Sliders With Pickle and Housemade Sauce

  • Fried Pickle Chips US$9.95

FOOD - SANDWICHES 15 dishes

  • BLT US$10.95

    Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato on Thick White Bread

  • Burger US$12.20

    Half Pound Burger!

  • Grilled Cheese US$8.95

    On Thick Sliced White Bread

  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$12.95

    Grilled Chicken Breast on a Bun with Lettuce, Tomato and Onion

  • Italian Hoagie US$12.95

    Ham, Hard Salami, Cooked Cappicola Salami & Provolone w/ Ital Dressing

  • Perch Sandwich US$18.95

    Served ona Bun With Lettuce, Tomato, and Onion

  • Perch Tacos US$18.95

    w /Shredded Cheese

  • Pot Roast Sandwich US$15.95

    Served Open Faced on Garlic Bread, with a Side of Mashed Potatoes and Horsey Sauce

  • Quesadilla US$12.95

    10” Flour Tortilla w/ Chicken, Cheese, Tomato & Red Onion

  • Salmon BLT US$16.95

    Served w/ Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, & Tartar On Choice of Bread

  • Turkey Club US$12.95

    Turkey & Bacon Piled High w/ American Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

  • Turkey Reuben US$12.95

    On Grilled Rye, w/ Kraut, Swiss Cheese & 1,000 Island Dressing

  • Hot Dog US$3.95

  • Chicken Salad Sandwich US$12.95

  • Corned Beef Reuben US$12.95

FOOD - BASKETS 7 dishes

  • Perch 1 # US$41.95

    Lightly Breaded & Deep Fried

  • Perch 1/2 # US$21.95

  • Clam Strip Basket US$14.95

  • Fried Shrimp Basket US$14.95

    Lightly Breaded, Served with Cocktail and boom boom Sauce and Lemon

  • Perch Basket US$21.95

    An Island Tradition!

  • Tender Basket US$14.95

    4 Tenders Served w/ BBQ Sauce

  • Walleye Bite Basket US$19.95

    Lake Erie Walleye Bites. Hand Cut

FOOD - DINNERS 1 dishes

  • Perch Dinner

    Deep Fried Lake Erie Yellow Perch

FOOD - DESSERTS 4 dishes

  • Lava Cake US$9.95

  • Ice Cream US$3.95

  • Key Lime Pie US$6.95

  • Fried Oreos (4) US$9.50

FOOD - Ala Carte 42 dishes

  • American Cheese US$0.75

  • Bacon US$0.75

  • Beer Cheese US$1.00

  • Bistro US$0.25

  • Blue Cheese US$0.25

  • Buffalo Ranch US$0.25

  • Buffalo Wing Sauce US$0.25

  • Bun Set-Up US$2.50

  • Cheddar Cheese US$0.75

  • Garlic Parm US$0.25

  • Grilled Chicken Breast US$7.95

  • Grilled Mushrooms US$0.75

  • Grilled Onions US$0.75

  • Honey Mustard US$0.25

  • Horsey Sauce US$0.25

  • Hot Bacon Dressing US$1.50

  • Italian US$0.25

  • Jalepenos US$0.75

  • Lemons US$0.25

  • Marinara US$0.25

  • Mashed Potatoes US$3.50

  • Mayo US$0.25

  • Mozz Cheese US$0.75

  • Oil & Vinegar US$0.25

  • Provolone Cheese US$0.75

  • Pepper Jack Cheese US$0.75

  • Pickle US$0.25

  • Piece White Bread US$0.50

  • Piece Wheat Bread US$0.50

  • Piece Rye Bread US$0.50

  • Piece Garlic Bread US$1.25

  • Piece Bread & Butter US$1.00

  • Ranch US$0.25

  • Salsa US$0.25

  • Saurkraut US$0.50

  • Sour Cream US$0.25

  • Swiss Cheese US$0.75

  • Taco Set-Up US$2.50

  • Tartar Sauce US$0.25

  • Thousand Island US$0.25

  • Asparagus US$4.95

  • Salmon Filet US$12.95

SOUPS & SALADS 10 dishes

  • Chicken Noodle Soup US$8.95

    Homemade!

  • Chili US$9.95

    Add Cheese Or Onions For 50¢ Each

  • Large Mixed Green Salad US$9.95

    w/ Cheese, Egg, Tomato, Onions

  • Side Salad US$7.95

    Mixed Greens, Shredded Cheese, Diced Tomatoes, & Diced Red Onions

  • Spinach Salad US$12.95

    Fresh Spinach, Egg, Bacon, Onion, Mushrooms, Tomato,& Mozzarella Cheese, Served w/ Balsamic

  • Small Spinach Salad US$8.95

    Spinach, Tomatoes, Onion, Mozzarella Cheese, and Bacon. Served with Balsamic Vinaigrette

  • Cole Slaw US$4.95

    Served w/ Garlic Bread

  • Cup Of Slaw US$2.50

  • Richie’s Famous Lobster Chowder US$15.00

  • Power Salad Bowl US$12.95

STARTERS 16 dishes

  • Bag Of Chips US$1.00

  • Cheese Curds US$8.95

    Garlic Cheese Curds From Wisconsin

  • French Fries US$7.95

    Basket Of French Fries To Share

  • Fried Green Beans US$8.95

    Served With Horsey Sauce

  • Nachos US$15.95

    Piled High w/ Cheese, Tomatoes & Onions. Served w/ Sour Cream & Salsa

  • Onion Rings US$9.95

    Served w/ Bistro Sauce

  • Pretzel US$9.95

    Served w/ Beer Cheese Dip

  • Small Fries US$3.95

  • Steak Bites US$17.95

    Sirloin Steak Grilled w/ Mushrooms & Onions & Served Over Garlic Bread

  • Tenders US$11.95

    4 Tenders Served w/ BBQ Sauce

  • Walleye Bites US$16.95

    Lightly Breaded Lake Erie Walleye Bites. Hand Cut.

  • Wings US$19.95

    Plain Buffalo BBQ Garlic Parmesan

  • Cheeseburger Sliders US$12.95

  • Ahi Tuna US$19.95

  • Chicken Sliders US$12.95

    Three Fried Chicken Sliders With Pickle and Housemade Sauce

  • Fried Pickle Chips US$9.95

SANDWICHES 15 dishes

  • BLT US$10.95

    Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato on Thick White Bread

  • Burger US$12.20

    Half Pound Burger!

  • Grilled Cheese US$8.95

    On Thick Sliced White Bread

  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$12.95

    Grilled Chicken Breast on a Bun with Lettuce, Tomato and Onion

  • Italian Hoagie US$12.95

    Ham, Hard Salami, Cooked Cappicola Salami & Provolone w/ Ital Dressing

  • Perch Sandwich US$18.95

    Served ona Bun With Lettuce, Tomato, and Onion

  • Perch Tacos US$18.95

    w /Shredded Cheese

  • Pot Roast Sandwich US$15.95

    Served Open Faced on Garlic Bread, with a Side of Mashed Potatoes and Horsey Sauce

  • Quesadilla US$12.95

    10” Flour Tortilla w/ Chicken, Cheese, Tomato & Red Onion

  • Salmon BLT US$16.95

    Served w/ Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, & Tartar On Choice of Bread

  • Turkey Club US$12.95

    Turkey & Bacon Piled High w/ American Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

  • Turkey Reuben US$12.95

    On Grilled Rye, w/ Kraut, Swiss Cheese & 1,000 Island Dressing

  • Hot Dog US$3.95

  • Chicken Salad Sandwich US$12.95

  • Corned Beef Reuben US$12.95

BASKETS 7 dishes

  • Perch 1 # US$41.95

    Lightly Breaded & Deep Fried

  • Perch 1/2 # US$21.95

  • Clam Strip Basket US$14.95

  • Fried Shrimp Basket US$14.95

    Lightly Breaded, Served with Cocktail and boom boom Sauce and Lemon

  • Perch Basket US$21.95

    An Island Tradition!

  • Tender Basket US$14.95

    4 Tenders Served w/ BBQ Sauce

  • Walleye Bite Basket US$19.95

    Lake Erie Walleye Bites. Hand Cut

DINNERS 1 dishes

  • Perch Dinner

    Deep Fried Lake Erie Yellow Perch

DESSERTS 4 dishes

  • Lava Cake US$9.95

  • Ice Cream US$3.95

  • Key Lime Pie US$6.95

  • Fried Oreos (4) US$9.50

Ala Carte 42 dishes

  • American Cheese US$0.75

  • Bacon US$0.75

  • Beer Cheese US$1.00

  • Bistro US$0.25

  • Blue Cheese US$0.25

  • Buffalo Ranch US$0.25

  • Buffalo Wing Sauce US$0.25

  • Bun Set-Up US$2.50

  • Cheddar Cheese US$0.75

  • Garlic Parm US$0.25

  • Grilled Chicken Breast US$7.95

  • Grilled Mushrooms US$0.75

  • Grilled Onions US$0.75

  • Honey Mustard US$0.25

  • Horsey Sauce US$0.25

  • Hot Bacon Dressing US$1.50

  • Italian US$0.25

  • Jalepenos US$0.75

  • Lemons US$0.25

  • Marinara US$0.25

  • Mashed Potatoes US$3.50

  • Mayo US$0.25

  • Mozz Cheese US$0.75

  • Oil & Vinegar US$0.25

  • Provolone Cheese US$0.75

  • Pepper Jack Cheese US$0.75

  • Pickle US$0.25

  • Piece White Bread US$0.50

  • Piece Wheat Bread US$0.50

  • Piece Rye Bread US$0.50

  • Piece Garlic Bread US$1.25

  • Piece Bread & Butter US$1.00

  • Ranch US$0.25

  • Salsa US$0.25

  • Saurkraut US$0.50

  • Sour Cream US$0.25

  • Swiss Cheese US$0.75

  • Taco Set-Up US$2.50

  • Tartar Sauce US$0.25

  • Thousand Island US$0.25

  • Asparagus US$4.95

  • Salmon Filet US$12.95

N/A BEVERAGES - Beverages 20 dishes

  • Coke US$2.50

  • Diet Coke US$2.50

  • Sprite US$2.50

  • Dr. Pepper US$2.50

  • Root Beer US$2.50

  • Mountain Dew US$2.50

  • Ginger Ale US$2.50

  • Pink Lemonade US$2.50

  • Cherry Cream Soda US$2.50

  • Orange Juice US$2.50

  • Cranberry Juice US$2.50

  • Grapefruit Juice US$2.50

  • Tomato Juice US$2.50

  • Milk US$2.50

  • Coffee US$2.50

  • Hot Tea US$2.50

  • Iced Tea US$2.50

  • Milkshake US$4.50

  • Hoppy US$4.00

  • Hot Chocolate US$3.00

N/A BEVERAGES - Kids Beverages 14 dishes

  • Coke US$1.50

  • Diet Coke US$1.50

  • Sprite US$1.50

  • Dr. Pepper US$1.50

  • Root Beer US$1.50

  • Mountain Dew US$1.50

  • Ginger Ale US$1.50

  • Pink Lemonade US$1.50

  • Cherry Cream Soda US$1.50

  • Orange Juice US$1.50

  • Cranberry Juice US$1.50

  • Grapefruit Juice US$1.50

  • Tomato Juice US$1.50

  • Milk US$1.50

Beverages 20 dishes

  • Coke US$2.50

  • Diet Coke US$2.50

  • Sprite US$2.50

  • Dr. Pepper US$2.50

  • Root Beer US$2.50

  • Mountain Dew US$2.50

  • Ginger Ale US$2.50

  • Pink Lemonade US$2.50

  • Cherry Cream Soda US$2.50

  • Orange Juice US$2.50

  • Cranberry Juice US$2.50

  • Grapefruit Juice US$2.50

  • Tomato Juice US$2.50

  • Milk US$2.50

  • Coffee US$2.50

  • Hot Tea US$2.50

  • Iced Tea US$2.50

  • Milkshake US$4.50

  • Hoppy US$4.00

  • Hot Chocolate US$3.00

Kids Beverages 14 dishes

  • Coke US$1.50

  • Diet Coke US$1.50

  • Sprite US$1.50

  • Dr. Pepper US$1.50

  • Root Beer US$1.50

  • Mountain Dew US$1.50

  • Ginger Ale US$1.50

  • Pink Lemonade US$1.50

  • Cherry Cream Soda US$1.50

  • Orange Juice US$1.50

  • Cranberry Juice US$1.50

  • Grapefruit Juice US$1.50

  • Tomato Juice US$1.50

  • Milk US$1.50

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

If you’re looking for a cozy and laid-back spot on Kelleys Island, The Village Pump is a must-visit. Located at 103 W Lakeshore Dr, this American restaurant has built a reputation for offering a comfortable dining experience with a variety of delicious options. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite, craving a late-night snack, or ready to enjoy a hearty meal, The Village Pump has something for everyone.

The restaurant’s menu features classic comfort food, small plates, and a variety of drinks that cater to all tastes. You can enjoy a refreshing cocktail, beer, or wine, while happy-hour specials offer both food and drink deals. Whether you’re in the mood for a cold beer after a day in the sun or a delicious coffee to kickstart your evening, The Village Pump has you covered.

For those who prefer dining in, the welcoming atmosphere invites you to relax and savor your meal. If you’re on the go or prefer to enjoy your food elsewhere, you can also choose takeaway or delivery options. The friendly service ensures that whether you're sitting down or taking food to go, you’ll have a great experience.

It’s not just about the food at The Village Pump; the vibe is just right for both locals and visitors to unwind and enjoy their time. With offerings like happy-hour drinks and late-night food, it’s clear that this place knows how to cater to all kinds of moods and moments. So, whether you're looking for a casual hangout or a tasty meal after a long day, The Village Pump is the perfect spot to enjoy some comfort food, great drinks, and a laid-back vibe.

Other menus in Kelleys Island

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Kelleys Island listings
Menu Directions